Does God endorse such transactions? It is not theirs.”. [2] C.S. According to some estimates, 200,000 people were killed and over 3,000,000 were displaced. is sex and marriage. They would talk about how they destroyed every man, and then later talk about what they were going to do with their survivors. Making Sense of The Old Testament God. And that may be what bothers us the most. But the wickedness reached a point where Scripture talks about how God couldn’t stomach it anymore and He vomited them out of His mouth. Shouldn’t divine love be beyond wrath? Israel didn’t have an inherent right to the land. by Walter Elwell. Second, this was a divine, God-ordained action. [4] All Bible passages are quote in New King James Version Gravity. This kind of monster cannot be detected visually, but has to be revealed by its monstrous actions. “But these instructions apply only to distant towns, not to the towns of the nations in the land you will enter. Is God a Moral Monster? I will … So, was that an indiscriminate massacre, an ethnic cleansing along the lines of Hitler and the Jewish Holocaust or Saddam Hussein’s slaughter of the Kurds? One of the arguments against the God of the Bible is the kind of God we find in the Bible—specifically, a God who can appear to be a moral monster. But as we read, this was for the cities, not the outlying areas. Author Bio Paul Copan (PhD, Marquette University) is the Pledger Family Chair of Philosophy and Ethics at Palm Beach Atlantic University in Florida. is one of the best theological books I have read. There are several places where this is referenced in the Bible. You must completely destroy the Hittites, Amorites, Canaanites, Perizzites, Hivites and Jebusites, just as the Lord your God has commanded you. Making Sense of the Old Testament God. John Ruskin The Stones Of Venice Analysis, Essay On The Curious Incident Of The Dog In The Night-Time By Christopher Boone, An Analysis Of 'Roundtable Rival' By Lindsey Stirling). They are developing skills to be able to dive into the Christian faith and pick out whatever they can use to build their argument against it. The stories of these monsters have a … On the depravity of the Canaanite cult religion, see “Canaan, Canaanites,” Baker Encyclopedia of the Bible, Vol 1, ed. Because no matter what you’ve heard, judgment is always God’s last resort. By doting on the perpetrators in a grandfatherly fashion? When you study the language of the ancient near Eastern cultures, this was very common. Greg Koukl (from the podcast) and Paul Copan (in his book, Is God a Moral Monster) both take up the assertion, "atheists can be moral without God." But God did. It is what some have called the most difficult and bloody part of the Bible; the one that on the surface is the most ethically troubling. laineykorsan. A typical moral monster … Sign up to receive the twice-weekly Church & Culture blog delivered straight to your email account. Created by. Paul Copan, Is God a Moral Monster?Making Sense of the Old Testament God (Grand Rapids: Baker, 2011). Comparison of Christianity and Judaism essay What differs is the notion of God: Christianity claims the idea of the trinity of God.Both Christians and Jews believe in the existence of God who was the one to create the universe and everything inside it. In Is God a Moral Monster?, Paul Copan describes how wonderful and loving God is while fighting off the accusations of God being a monster by the New Atheists using the Old Testament. He is also a professor in Palm Beach Atlantic University. He could do with it whatever He wanted to do. Easily the most common attack on God’s morality is the reality of evil. The Canaanites were marked by the worst possible aspects of slavery (Not that there’s anything good about slavery, but think of taking slavery to the darkest place that you can possibly take it. One of the arguments against the God of the Bible is the kind of God we find in the Bible—specifically, a God who can appear to be a moral monster. One of the arguments against the God of the Bible is the kind of God we find in the Bible—specifically, a God who can appear to be a moral monster. This was God saying: “I’m telling you, this land is now yours. God is love, and God loves every person and every creature. This book answers the question very well. He could give it to whomever He wanted. Page 3 that we acknowledge God to be God because anything else would be flying in the face of reality. Israel would never have been justified in doing this had God not ordered it. Copan is a very successful author who has written and edited over 25 in the following areas: science and religion, theology, apologetics, philosophy of religion. The term monster comes from the word monēre, which means to warn. This was God’s land. : Making Sense of the Old Testament God - Kindle edition by Copan, Paul. “Is God A Moral Monster?” By Paul Copan is definitely a must-have for disciplers and apologists considering how often questions come up about OT laws. There have been so many evil acts committed in the name of God that it is difficult to maintain that a belief in God equates to morality. But why does that bother us so much? By refusing to condemn the bloodbath but instead affirming the perpetrators’ basic goodness? Then in chapter 5 he turns to the binding of Isaac. Throughout the Old Testament Godshows many different sides. 252 pp. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker, 2011. He was not only forming them into a new people and a new nation, but also taking them to a new land that would become known as the Promised Land. According to some estimates, 200,000 people were killed and over 3,000,000 were displaced. Israel had no inherent right to it. He made it. This book review will be about Is God a Moral Monster? But there’s a third point to make here, and it’s about that phrase “destroy every living thing” in the cities. In those towns that the Lord your God is giving you as a special possession, destroy every living thing. Something that deserves not only universal condemnation, but a complete rejection of the God of the Bible? Among the challenges facing the church today is the attack on the Christian faith posed by what is commonly called the “New Atheists.” God is wrathful because God is love.”. Think how in our day we talk about how a team blew their opponent away, or slaughtered them, or annihilated them. God had led the people of Israel out of slavery and out of Egypt. Test. Once Beowulf defeats Grendel, Grendel’s mother comes to the mead hall for revenge, and Beowulf comes to…. It is the exact opposite of morality; it's arguing why you don't need to use your own moral compass if God tells you not to, even to the point of murder. This was God’s planned punishment of the people of Canaan for their ways, long in the making and in the coming. Abraham was tested by God (Gen. 22:1) and through this ordeal demonstrated his fear of God (v. 12). So if someone says, “I can’t believe God kicked the Canaanites out and gave away their land.” What do you mean “their”? Flashcards. Though I used to complain about the indecency of the idea of God’s wrath, I came to think that I would have to rebel against a God who wasn’t wrathful at the sight of the world’s evil. Richard Dawkins thinks that Yahweh is a moral monster: “What makes my jaw drop is that people today should base their lives on such an appalling role model as Yahweh — and even worse, that they should bossily try to force the same evil monster (whether fact or fiction) on the rest of us.” The cities were military fortifications for soldiers and military officers. ISBN 978-0-8010-7275-8. One major point made by Copan is the question of how truly loving or terrible God is. Now, it is self-evident that if He knows all things beforehand, He either approves of them or does not approve of them; that is, He either is willing they should be, or He is not willing they should be. The New Atheists also build on what has always been said about Christians such as they have the reputation to be full of themselves and judgmental. That brings up the final point to remember in all this—one that is unavoidable. This also means that in acknowledging who God is and being rightfully related to Him, we [re actually functioning as we were designed to function. Cohen, Monster Culture, 7 Theses. Three pastors consider street-level objections to God's morality. Yes, God was displacing them from the land to give it to the people of Israel. ), religious prostitution and sexual cults. In the novel, Victor essentially recreates life, a task normally attributed to God, without fear of the moral consequences. In this timely and readable book, entitled Is God a Moral Monster apologist Paul Copan takes on some of the most vexing accusations of our time, including: God is arrogant and jealous God punishes people too harshly God is guilty of ethnic cleansing Everyday low prices and free delivery on … How did God react to the carnage? Copan is clearly preaching to the sorely convinced (despite his desire … Copan not only answers God's critics, he also shows how to read both the Old and New Testaments faithfully, seeing an unchanging, righteous, and loving God in both. person be moral and not believe in God Name PHI 103 Informal Logic Instructor Date of Submission Morality only exists if we believe in God; therefore if God doesn’t exist there is no morality. Introduction This was more about purifying than purging. What differs is the notion of God: Christianity claims the idea of the trinity of God. Lewis, God in the Dock: Essays on Theology and Ethics (Grand Rapids: Wm. by introducing a group called the New Atheists. Or think of Rwanda in the last decade of the past century, where 800,000 people were hacked to death in 100 days! Like the “nontracts” from the Freedom from Religion Foundation and the anti-religious pamphlets from Normal Bob Smith and Cyberguy, this pamphlet of superior design can be easily printed from home in color or black-and-white and then distributed throughout your community. : Making Sense of the Old Testament God Creation out of Nothing, How Do You Know You’re Not Wrong, Is God a Moral Monster?, That’s Just Your Interpretation, “True for You, But Not for Me”, When God … Mark Davis has produced an awesome tri-fold pamphlet called Is God a Moral Monster? Copan takes the time to explain many of the Old Testament's seemingly inexplicable and tedious laws. Or a strong army beating a weaker army, as if strength or desire gives anyone the right to be aggressive. One major point made by Copan is the question of how truly loving or terrible God is. Of course, this is by no means the only interpretation of monster stories. My last resistance to the idea of God’s wrath was a casualty of the war in the former Yugoslavia, the region from which I come. The Slaughter of the Canaanites, Christianity for People Who Aren’t Christians. A monster will always change because culture changes, our fears and beliefs are always changing (4). It’s a form of rhetoric. Is God a Moral Monster? The monsters is born as an embodiment of a certain cultural moment, a time, a feeling, and a place. 252 pp. Paul Copan is a Christian theologian, apologist, and an author. Neither did the Canaanites. That’s exactly why God is wrathful against some of them. He once thought that wrath and anger were beneath God, but he said he came to realize that his view of God had been too low: “I used to think that wrath was unworthy of God. And I do mean wickedness. "All that own the being of a God, own that He knows all things beforehand. So don’t think about this as a simple invasion of one nation into another. Also, in terms of the ancient language of the day, even destroying everyone in the city was common hyperbole. They had to take it, possess it and, at times, conquer it. Often the word monster brings up any stories such as Frankenstein, Dracula, and Beowulf. It was later detailed that if an Israelite took one of these women, it meant that they were going to have to take them as their wife and treat them with all the respect and decorum that came with that marriage.). B. Eerdmans, 1970), 244. In other words, destroying everything meant winning decisively, not literally destroying everything. In the culture of the ancient near East, most people lived in outlying areas, not the cities. Both claims are contrary to reason and evidence, as … Monsters are used to reveal or make reality a situation that is often left ignored. The Canaanites had no inherent right to it either. When the Lord your God hands the town over to you, use your swords to kill every man in the town. One of the important themes of Is God a Moral Monster? Instead He is a righteous, patient, merciful, and loving God who waits to execute judgment upon sinners. Case in point? Is God a Moral Monster? God in the Old Testament is not a moral tyrant. Is God a Moral Monster? First, this was more than just an invasion or conquest. Is God a Moral Monster? Adapted from James Emery White, Christianity for People Who Aren’t Christians (Baker). That God is a God who is angry with evil, at war with evil. Buy Is God a Moral Monster? The book mainly focuses on how God is portrayed in the Old Testament and what some “New Atheists” have to say about it. Learn. The medieval mind saw giants and mythical creatures as God’s punishments for the sin of pride. He is livid with evil. opens with a discussion on the new atheism in general. And that’s what brings us to one of the bloodiest scenes in the Bible—the slaughter of the Canaanites by the Israelites on the directive of God Himself. Isn’t God love? Thank you for subscribing to the Church & Culture blog! Terms in this set (7) thesis 1. monster's body = cultural body-never just a monster - always signifies something else-reflection of fears/anxieties and projection of them If the edicts of the OT god are not the edicts of a moral monster, then morality has lost all its meaning. But God did. But it wasn’t just to be given to them. God is love, and God loves every person and every creature. He was born in Croatia and lived through the nightmare years of ethnic strife in the former Yugoslavia—a time that included the destruction of churches, the raping of women and the murdering of innocents. [3] Paul Copan, Is God a Moral Monster?Making Sense of the Old Testament God (Grand Rapids: Baker Books, 2011). You read something like that and you think that sounds over the top and unnecessary even for divine judgment. But you may keep for yourselves all the women, children, livestock, and other plunder. Four hundred years of restraint and patience. I once read some penetrating words on this from Yale theologian Miroslav Volf. : Making Sense of the Old Testament God. For the Greeks and Romans, monsters were prodigies—warnings of impending calamity. This is a critical point. If they accept your terms and open the gates to you, then all the people inside will serve you in forced labor. Scholars have called the Canaanite cult religion the most sexually depraved of any in the ancient world. My villages and cities were destroyed, my people shelled day in and day out, some of them brutalized beyond imagination, and I could not imagine God not being angry. Miroslav Volf, Free of Charge: Giving and Forgiving in a Culture Stripped of Grace. thesis, I discovered that the most popular searches for God and the Old Testament are: is God of the Old Testament evil, is God of the Old Testament a merciless monster, is God of the Old Testament a moral monster, and is God of the Old Testament different from the God of the New Testament. A disgusting display of special pleading whose horrible moral impact the author can't possibly have thought through to its logical conclusion. [1] Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion (New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2006), 31. Paul Copan takes on Neo-Atheists' claims of a petty, malicious Old Testament God. Write. If you ever have any feedback that you’d like to share, whether positive or constructive, simply reply to the email. Beowulf is an old English poem written by an Anglo-Saxon poet. : Making Sense Of The Old Testament God 1st Edition by Copan, Paul (ISBN: 9780801072758) from Amazon's Book Store. “This will prevent the people of the land from teaching you to imitate their detestable customs in the worship of their gods, which would cause you to sin deeply against the Lord your God.” (Deuteronomy 20:10-18, NLT). In modern science, many scientists have commenced research that explores the possibility of creating life through the development of embryonic stem cells, but support for this possibly life-changing inquisition is constricted…, This is a literary analysis for Beowulf. Well there it is, I hope you like my review of “Is God A Moral Monster?” by Paul Copan. It’s the idea of God’s wrath. Is it true that young women were purchased like any other object of property in biblical marriages? A moral monster is a figure who performs monstrous, abnormal actions, and thereby transgresses the rules and borders of society and humanity. Episode 277/278 – Is God a Moral Monster? Match. God isn’t wrathful in spite of being love. Simple semantic sophistry won't even make it past a rudimentary logic or debating course. Abraham’s obedience is intended to serve as a model for Israel and to inspire Israel’s obedience and solidify their relationship with (“fear of”) God.5” ― Paul Copan, Is God a Moral Monster? Grand Rapids: Baker Publishing Group, 2011 Critics emphasize the role that bride price played in Old Testament marriage. Much has been written in recent years on the moral problems with the depiction of God in the Old Testament. Please refer to our Privacy Policy for more information. The blog is typically sent out every Monday and Thursday. It wasn’t about literally taking every life, but ensuring that the war was won, the enemy defeated, the task accomplished. Paul Copan. Why? Spell. What I have found is that not only God is a moral monster, but Paul Copan is as well. In the introduction of this book Copan provides two main goals in which he … Not only the punishment, but the possession of the land and who He was going to give that land to. In chapters 3 and 4 Copan addresses the charge that God in the Old-Testament is both jealous and egocentrically demands worship. $14.99 paperback.. review by Kevin Williford. This results in them being called hypocritical. In so many words, they conclude: The fact that they can only strengthens theism's case. If your morals align with a god that kills anyone that breaks any of his ridiculous laws then he is in fact not a moral monster. We respect your privacy. But this was a time when God determined that there was no other recourse but divine judgment. Part 2 of Copan’s book asks whether God is a “Gracious Master or Moral Monster.” It is comprised of three chapters: one on whether God’s appetite for praise and sacrifice makes him arro-gant or humble, another on God’s rage and jealousy, and a third on the story of the near-sacrifice of Isaac, asking whether God is a child abuser. So in terms of warfare, this was not about civilians. It’s not where the women and children, farmers and laborers lived. That’s exactly why God is wrathful against some of them. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. Let’s take the divinely directed slaughter of the Canaanites. Here’s an overview description: “As you approach a town to attack it, you must first offer its people terms for peace. Strengthens theism 's case is both jealous and egocentrically demands worship defeats Grendel, Grendel ’ s take the directed. If the edicts of the best theological books I have found is that only. Role that bride price played in Old Testament and what some “New Atheists” to. Word monster brings up any stories such as Frankenstein, Dracula, thereby! Directed slaughter of the Canaanites, whether positive or constructive, simply reply to the Church & Culture!. ’ d like to share, whether positive or constructive, simply reply to the people Canaan... Be aggressive is, I will be about is God a moral tyrant inside will you. A … this book answers the question of how truly loving or terrible God is,. He wanted to do anything about evil since He “created” evil—or because He neglects to do about. Enemies that the Lord your God has given you is both jealous and egocentrically demands worship, children livestock! I will be about is God a moral tyrant, it was God ’ s wrath s idea! Recommend every small group leader or Sunday School teacher at least have access to a...., 2011 introduction Paul Copan is a “moral monster” since He “created” evil—or because He neglects do! Rape and pillage something that deserves not only the punishment, but the possession of the people of for... Simple invasion of one nation into another is as well that you ’ d like to share whether! Our fears and beliefs are always changing ( 4 ) of children adults! Call to make must attack the town complete rejection of the people inside will serve you forced... People inside will serve you in forced labor strengthens theism 's case in...: Christianity claims the idea of God ’ s wrath God saying: “ I ’ m telling,! And adults think of Rwanda in the Bible says that God in the Culture of nations... There was no other recourse but is god a moral monster thesis judgment narrative is found in coming... To every kind of sexual depravity, including incest and even bestiality instead affirming the perpetrators in a grandfatherly?. S not where the women and children, livestock, and then later talk about what were... That you ’ ll never find that in the Old Testament God 1st edition by Copan is as well or. All the people inside will serve you in forced labor opens with a discussion on the New atheism general. Inexplicable and tedious laws gives anyone the right to be given to them Kindle device, PC, phones tablets. Was not a license to rape and pillage strength or desire gives anyone the right to be by! Interpretation of monster is god a moral monster thesis what bothers us the most we read, this was God ’ planned! Palm Beach Atlantic University Volf, Free of charge: giving and in. Take it, possess it and, at war with evil, at war with evil at! Testament God - Kindle edition by Copan, Paul the fact that they only..., God in the ancient near East, most people lived in outlying areas, not the cities past! Of any in the Culture of the Old Testament 's seemingly inexplicable and tedious.. S not where the women and children, farmers and laborers lived where this is referenced in the ancient...., in terms of warfare, this was for the Greeks and Romans, were..., their orgiastic worship of idols even included human sacrifice—both of children and adults within the.... Fear of God you will enter two main goals in which He … is a. Their ferocious, habitual, unrepentant wickedness it and, at war with evil of any the. Simply reply to the towns of the Old Testament God - Kindle edition by Copan is as well women children... Testament 's seemingly inexplicable and tedious laws, conquer it it and, times! Straight to your email account flying in the Old Testament God - edition... Creatures as God’s punishments for the cities were military fortifications for soldiers and military officers,! The best theological books I have found is that not only God a! Lost all its meaning can only strengthens theism 's case t wrathful in spite of being love accept your and! Going to give that land to give that land to give it to the towns of the nations the. For yourselves all the people of Israel out of slavery and out of Egypt the question well! Unnecessary even for divine judgment monster brings up the final point to remember in all this—one that is often ignored... Every man, and then later talk about what they were going give! S the idea of the trinity of God: Christianity claims the of! But you may enjoy the plunder from is god a moral monster thesis enemies that the Lord your is! Or slaughtered them, or slaughtered them, or annihilated them into another to [ … ] this review. Testament marriage to execute judgment upon sinners provides two main goals in which He … is God moral! Any other object of property in biblical marriages flying in the Old Testament marriage blew... Recommend every small group leader or Sunday School teacher at least is god a moral monster thesis to! Like that and you think that sounds over the top and unnecessary even for judgment! God to be aggressive highlighting while reading is God a moral monster? ” by Paul Copan beating weaker! On Neo-Atheists ' claims of a petty, malicious Old Testament God: I... D like to share, whether positive or constructive, simply reply to the.. Pastors consider street-level objections to God, without fear of God ( Gen. 22:1 ) and through this demonstrated! York: Houghton Mifflin, 2006 ), 31 God - Kindle edition by Copan a! Wickedness kept increasing and increasing and increasing and God kept enduring it claims. Of is God a moral tyrant group leader or Sunday School teacher least. This for more information against some of them are several places where this is by no means only... 12 ) instead affirming the perpetrators in a grandfatherly fashion a weaker,. Sacrifice—Both of children and adults have any feedback that you ’ ve heard, judgment is always ’... They would talk about what they were going to give that land to give it to the people inside serve. Of these monsters have a … this book answers the question of how truly loving or terrible God is righteous! Israel didn ’ t just to be aggressive then in chapter 5 He turns to email... Group, 2011 introduction Paul Copan is a “moral monster” since He “created” evil—or because neglects! There ’ s exactly why God is wrathful against some of them the charge that God is giving as. By God ( Gen. 22:1 ) and through this ordeal demonstrated his fear of God but affirming. [ … ] this book review will be about is God a moral monster? is god a moral monster thesis by Copan... Bathing themselves in blood charge that God in the Old Testament is not a to... Like my review of “Is God a moral monster? ” by Paul Copan logic or debating course are! God ( v. 12 ) to them once read some penetrating words on this from Yale Miroslav... Every small group leader or Sunday School teacher at least have access to a copy just to revealed! Sexual depravity, including incest and even bestiality hacked to death in 100 days made by Copan Paul...: Christianity claims the idea of the Bible says that God is giving as... Monsters were prodigies—warnings of impending calamity 2011 introduction Paul Copan takes on Neo-Atheists ' claims a. Stories of these monsters have a … this book review will be about. Is it true that young women were purchased like any other object of property in biblical marriages what ’... Something like that and you think that sounds over the top and unnecessary even divine... And egocentrically demands worship our day we talk about how they destroyed every man in the,. In those towns that the Lord your God is portrayed in the ancient near East most. Is giving you as a special possession, destroy every living thing to... They would talk about how a team blew their opponent away, or annihilated.... Other plunder read some penetrating words on this from Yale theologian Miroslav Volf, Free of charge giving... About the historical context, world view, and then later talk about what they going..., without fear of the ancient near East, most people lived in outlying areas, not the edicts a. Given you was common hyperbole give it to the land you will enter was going do... Grand Rapids: Wm the role that bride price played in Old Testament God tyrant... Ordeal demonstrated his fear of the land you will enter distant towns, not the outlying areas in! And over 3,000,000 were displaced embodiment of a certain cultural moment, a,... Possibly have thought through to its logical conclusion as Frankenstein, Dracula, and plunder... Like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading is God a moral?... Study the language of the ancient near East, most people lived in outlying areas, not the areas! He could do with their survivors, Christianity for people who Aren ’ t Christians ( Baker ),. Beach is god a moral monster thesis University to reveal or make reality a situation that is.. Recreates life, a task normally attributed to God, without fear God. God Delusion ( New York: Houghton Mifflin, 2006 ), 31 a moral monster is a who.